Frugal Deals Hub is reader-supported. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links.
Home › Comparisons › Kirkland vs Great Value paper towels
By Darren · Published Nov 16, 2026 · Prices last verified Nov 12, 2026
How do Kirkland vs Great Value paper towels compare on cost per sheet?
This post helps a bulk kitchen shopper decide how Kirkland vs Great Value paper towels compare on cost per sheet, with or without a Costco membership.
We used store-page prices only, including where Amazon Basics lands on the same unit. This is simple division, not a hands-on test of strength, absorbency or softness. Prices were checked Nov 12, 2026, between 4:43 and 4:45 AM ET.
Table of Contents
Split verdict. Sheet count and square footage point in different directions. Great Value Ultra Strong, 12 Triple Rolls is the cheapest verified pack on cost per 100 sheets, at about $1.0086 ($19.97 for 1,980 sheets), with no membership required. Kirkland Signature Paper Towels at the Seattle 98101 warehouse is about $1.0932 per 100 sheets ($20.99 for 1,920 sheets; warehouse prices vary by location) and about $0.0205 per sq ft, the lowest area price here. A Costco membership is required for Kirkland. Membership fee share estimate: Costco $65/yr ÷ 12 trips ≈ $5.42 per trip.
BUY Kirkland at the warehouse on cost per square foot only if you already have a membership and are comparing coverage. Great Value is about $0.0224 per sq ft. Costco.com Kirkland ($23.99) loses to Great Value on both units ($1.2495 per 100 sheets and $0.0234 per sq ft). Amazon Basics Flex-Sheets is the Amazon alternative, at about $1.2700 per 100 sheets ($22.86 for 1,800 sheets). The listing does not state total square footage. It is not a price dupe.


Kirkland vs Great Value paper towels: which pack costs less per sheet?
Price status:
- Kirkland Signature Paper Towels, 2-ply, item 512599, 12 individually wrapped rolls, 160 sheets/roll = 1,920 sheets, 11 in x 7 in, 1,026 sq ft stated, $20.99 in-warehouse at Seattle 98101: Price checked Nov 12, 2026, 4:43 AM ET at Costco. In Stock. Warehouse prices vary by region. Membership required.
- Same item, $23.99 on Costco.com: Price checked Nov 12, 2026, 4:43 AM ET. In Stock for Seattle 98101. Membership required.
- Great Value Ultra Strong Paper Towels, 12 Triple Rolls (Walmart item 15106373822), 165 split sheets/roll = 1,980 sheets, 11 in x 5.9 in, 892.2 sq ft stated, $19.97 (the page also showed a “was” price of $22.56): Price checked Nov 12, 2026, 4:45 AM ET at Walmart. Sold and shipped by Walmart.com. No membership.
- Amazon Basics 2-Ply Flex-Sheets Paper Towels (B09BWFX1L6), $22.86: Price checked Nov 12, 2026, 4:45 AM ET at Amazon. The listing is 12 rolls = 40 regular rolls, 150 sheets/roll = 1,800 sheets, and says packaging may vary. The official pack photo shows two 6-roll packs, each reading “6 XXL = 20 Regular,” 150 2-ply sheets, and 412.5 sq ft (2 × 412.5 = 825 sq ft calculated from the box photo, not stated on the listing). No membership.
- These packs are different roll types. The table compares them on total sheets and, where stated, total square feet. Target and Sam’s Club prices were UNVERIFIED. Subscribe & Save prices are not used.
Paper towels, cost per 100 sheets
| # | Retailer | Price | Qty | Membership / buy | Cost per unit | vs. best |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Walmart (Great Value Ultra Strong 12 Triple, 1,980 sheets) | $19.97 | 19.8 100 sheets | — | $1.009/100 sheet | Best |
| 2 | Costco warehouse (Kirkland paper towels, 1,920 sheets, Seattle 98101) | $20.99 | 19.2 100 sheets | — | $1.093/100 sheet | +8.4% |
| 3 | Costco.com (Kirkland paper towels, 1,920 sheets) | $23.99 | 19.2 100 sheets | — | $1.249/100 sheet | +23.9% |
| 4 | Amazon (Amazon Basics Flex-Sheets, 1,800 sheets) | $22.86 | 18 100 sheets | — | $1.270/100 sheet | +25.9% |
Membership fees are spread across your purchases per year. Prices change often — confirm at the retailer.
| Product | Retailer | Price | Sheets | Sq ft | Per 100 sheets, no fee | Per sq ft, no fee | Est. per 100 sheets, with fee share | Join just for this (per 100 sheets) | Checked (ET) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kirkland Signature Paper Towels | Costco warehouse (Seattle 98101; prices vary by location) | $20.99 | 1,920 | 1,026 | $1.0932 | $0.0205 | $1.3755 | $4.4786 | Nov 12, 4:43 AM |
| Kirkland Signature Paper Towels | Costco.com | $23.99 | 1,920 | 1,026 | $1.2495 | $0.0234 | $1.5318 | $4.6349 | Nov 12, 4:43 AM |
| Great Value Ultra Strong, 12 Triple | Walmart.com | $19.97 | 1,980 | 892.2 | $1.0086 | $0.0224 | $1.0086 (no membership) | n/a | Nov 12, 4:45 AM |
| Amazon Basics Flex-Sheets | Amazon | $22.86 | 1,800 | 825 (from box photo) | $1.2700 | $0.0277 (from box photo) | $1.2700 (no membership) | n/a | Nov 12, 4:45 AM |
Prices last verified Nov 12, 2026, 4:43–4:45 AM ET. Costco warehouse prices are for Seattle 98101 and vary by region. Amazon and Walmart prices may vary by ZIP. We don’t have 90 days of our own verified prices, so we make no claims about recent lows or price history.
Why this verdict?
Great Value is the cheapest verified pack on cost per 100 sheets: $19.97 ÷ 1,980 × 100 = $1.0086, with no membership. Kirkland at the warehouse is $20.99 ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $1.0932, about 8% more per 100 sheets. Costco.com is $23.99 ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $1.2495. Amazon Basics is $22.86 ÷ 1,800 × 100 = $1.2700, the highest verified per-100-sheets price here, and not a price dupe.
In the Kirkland vs Great Value paper towels matchup, the sheet-size caveat matters. Great Value’s box and listing give 165 split sheets per Triple roll, at 11 in x 5.9 in, or about 64.9 square inches. Kirkland’s box reads 11 in x 7 in, or 77 square inches per sheet (Costco also states 1,026 sq ft over 1,920 sheets). Great Value’s lower cost per 100 sheets is partly smaller sheets.
On area, Kirkland at the warehouse is $20.99 ÷ 1,026 = $0.0205 per sq ft, cheaper than Great Value at $19.97 ÷ 892.2 = $0.0224, so the warehouse pack is a BUY on coverage only for a member already making the trip. Costco.com, at $23.99 ÷ 1,026 = $0.0234, loses to Great Value on both units.
With estimated fee shares charged to this one Kirkland pack, the warehouse unit becomes ($20.99 + $5.42) ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $1.3755 per 100 sheets and ($20.99 + $5.42) ÷ 1,026 = $0.0257 per sq ft. Costco.com becomes $1.5318 and $0.0287. Those fee figures are estimates. With that trip share, Kirkland is not cheaper than Great Value on either unit. This is a price comparison only; we did not test the towels.
Who should skip a Costco paper-towel run?
- No Costco membership, if you would join only for this pack. Join-only math is ($20.99 + $65) ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $4.4786 per 100 sheets in-warehouse and $4.6349 online, far above Great Value at $1.0086. Even the estimated $5.42 trip share pushes Kirkland above Great Value on both units. Paper towels alone are a thin reason to join.
- Shoppers who only want the lowest cost per sheet. Great Value is $1.0086 per 100 sheets; Kirkland at the warehouse is $1.0932.
- Anyone ordering this pack from Costco.com. At $23.99, it loses to Great Value on both units ($1.2495 vs $1.0086 per 100 sheets, and $0.0234 vs $0.0224 per sq ft).
- Shoppers who need a confirmed non-Seattle warehouse price. Warehouse prices vary by region; the Costco warehouse figure is Seattle 98101 only.
What is the no-membership alternative?
Great Value Ultra Strong, 12 Triple Rolls is the no-membership pick in Kirkland vs Great Value paper towels and the winner on cost per 100 sheets, at $19.97, or $1.0086 per 100 sheets ($0.0224 per sq ft). It is sold and shipped by Walmart.com. Amazon Basics 2-Ply Flex-Sheets is the Amazon alternative at $22.86, or $1.2700 per 100 sheets. The listing is 12 rolls = 40 regular and says packaging may vary; the official photo shows two 6-roll packs. It is not a price dupe.
If you already shop at Costco and are comparing coverage, the warehouse pack is still the lower area price at $0.0205 per sq ft. For the same per-sheet method on a different product, see Kirkland vs Charmin toilet paper, also priced per sheet. That post is about toilet paper, not paper towels.
How we calculated cost per sheet
To compare Kirkland vs Great Value paper towels on the same footing, we used cost per 100 sheets = price ÷ total sheets × 100. Kirkland (12 × 160 = 1,920): $20.99 ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $1.0932; $23.99 ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $1.2495. Great Value (12 × 165 = 1,980 split sheets): $19.97 ÷ 1,980 × 100 = $1.0086. Amazon Basics (12 × 150 = 1,800): $22.86 ÷ 1,800 × 100 = $1.2700.
Cost per square foot from stated totals: Kirkland $20.99 ÷ 1,026 = $0.0205 and $23.99 ÷ 1,026 = $0.0234; Great Value’s listing and box state 892.2 sq ft (11 in × 5.9 in × 1,980 ÷ 144 = 892.4 sq ft, so the stated total reflects rounded sheet dimensions); $19.97 ÷ 892.2 = $0.0224. Kirkland’s box also reads 11 in x 7 in.
The Amazon Basics listing does not state total square footage; from the official pack photo, two 6-roll packs each marked 412.5 sq ft would be 825 sq ft, and $22.86 ÷ 825 = $0.0277 per sq ft. That $0.0277 figure is calculated from the box photo, not the listing, and is not used in the verdict.
With fee (estimate: Costco $65 ÷ 12 ≈ $5.42, from Costco’s membership page): ($20.99 + $5.42) ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $1.3755 and ÷ 1,026 = $0.0257; ($23.99 + $5.42) ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $1.5318 and ÷ 1,026 = $0.0287. Join-only: ($20.99 + $65) ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $4.4786; ($23.99 + $65) ÷ 1,920 × 100 = $4.6349. No fee was added to the Walmart or Amazon rows. We compared published prices and listings; we did not test the towels. See how we calculate Real Value for the full method. Warehouse prices are for Seattle 98101 and vary by region.
What do shoppers ask about Kirkland vs Great Value paper towels?
Is Kirkland cheaper than Great Value per sheet?
Not on the prices we checked. Kirkland at the Seattle 98101 warehouse is $1.0932 per 100 sheets, and Great Value is $1.0086. With the estimated membership trip share added, Kirkland rises to $1.3755.
Is Kirkland cheaper per square foot?
At the warehouse, yes. Kirkland comes to $0.0205 per square foot versus $0.0224 for Great Value. That changes once you add the estimated $5.42 trip share ($0.0257), and Costco.com ($0.0234) loses on this unit too.
Why is Great Value cheaper per sheet if Kirkland wins per square foot?
Great Value’s box lists 165 split sheets per Triple roll at 11 in x 5.9 in (about 64.9 square inches). Kirkland’s box lists 11 in x 7 in (77 square inches). Smaller sheets help Great Value’s per-sheet number.
Where does Amazon Basics land, and what about Bounty?
Amazon Basics is $1.2700 per 100 sheets, so it is the Amazon alternative rather than a price dupe. A grocery Bounty Double or Mega pack price was not verified in this check, so we left Bounty out of the table.
Where do these prices come from?
- Costco.com: Kirkland Signature Paper Towels, 2-ply, 160 sheets × 12 rolls (item 512599)
- Walmart: Great Value Ultra Strong Paper Towels, 12 Triple Rolls (item 15106373822)
- Amazon: Amazon Basics 2-Ply Flex-Sheets Paper Towels, 12 rolls (B09BWFX1L6)
- Costco membership page ($65/yr)