If you have a newborn at home, you wash a lot. Spit-up, blowouts, milk stains — the laundry never stops. So the question is not just “which detergent is gentle?” It is also “what does each wash cost?”

We checked both prices and did the math. Here is the short answer: Dreft costs about 79% more per load than Kirkland Free & Clear.
The Math (Simple Formula)
Cost per load = Price ÷ Number of loads on the label
That is all. No hidden math.
| Kirkland Ultra Clean Free & Clear | Dreft Stage 1 Newborn | |
|---|---|---|
| Where we checked | Costco.com | Amazon |
| Size | 194 fl oz | 150 fl oz |
| Loads on the label | 146 loads | 114 loads |
| Price checked 2026-11-18 | $17.89 | $24.94 |
| Cost per load | $17.89 ÷ 146 = $0.12 | $24.94 ÷ 114 = $0.22 |
Costco.com itself lists Kirkland at $0.12 per load. Dreft works out to about 22 cents a load.
Difference: $0.10 per load. Dreft costs 79% more per load.
Per 100 loads:
- Kirkland: $12.25
- Dreft: $21.88
- You save: $9.62 per 100 loads
If you do 3 baby loads a week (156 loads a year), you save about $15.01 a year. If the whole family uses the same detergent for 5 loads a week, you save about $25.02 a year.
One note: the $17.89 online price is a Black Friday deal — $3.60 off the $21.49 regular price, valid through 12/20/26. Kirkland’s warehouse price is $14.89 at our check, so the saving can be bigger in-store. We used the online price because anyone can check it.
What Each One Is
Kirkland Signature Ultra Clean Free & Clear
- Costco’s own brand. You need a Costco membership to buy it.
- Free & Clear means no dyes and no perfumes.
- Hypoallergenic, made for HE and standard washers.
- This is not a baby-only detergent. It is a whole-family detergent that parents use for baby clothes too.
- No Amazon link — it is Costco-only.
Dreft Stage 1 Newborn

- The classic baby detergent. Dreft calls it the pediatrician-recommended brand.
- Made for newborn skin, hypoallergenic.
- It is NOT fragrance-free — it has a light baby scent.
- 150 oz jug, 114 loads, $24.94 on Amazon at our check.
- Dreft has 45,923 reviews on Amazon for the Stage 1 listing.

Is Dreft Worth the Extra Cost?
Honest answer: for most babies, no.
Here is why parents say that. Many parents on Reddit say the same thing we found: a Free & Clear detergent does the same job, and Dreft is mostly marketing. One parent put it plainly — Kirkland Free & Clear is half the cost of Tide and way cheaper than Dreft, and it works for the whole family.
Dreft’s main selling point is the baby scent and the “made for babies” label. But if your baby has eczema or very sensitive skin, doctors say the thing to watch is fragrance, not the brand name. Dreft has fragrance. Kirkland Free & Clear does not.
That said, Dreft is still a good detergent. It cleans spit-up and formula stains well, and a lot of parents trust it because their own parents used it. If you love the Dreft smell and you do not mind paying 22 cents a load, keep using it. We are not here to tell you it is bad.
But if you want the same gentle wash for less money, Kirkland wins on price.
When to Pick Which One
Pick Kirkland Free & Clear if:
- You already have a Costco membership
- You want one detergent for the whole family, baby included
- You want fragrance-free and dye-free
- You want the lowest cost per load — $0.12
Pick Dreft Stage 1 if:
- You do not have Costco membership and you do not want one
- You want a baby-specific detergent with the classic baby scent
- You buy on Amazon and want it delivered
- You are fine paying $0.22 a load
Our Verdict
We would buy Kirkland.
It costs $0.12 a load against Dreft’s $0.22, it has no fragrance and no dyes, and you can use it for everyone’s clothes — not just the baby’s. That is the whole point of a dupe: same job, less money.
Dreft is fine, but you pay 79% more per load for a scent and a baby label.
FAQ

Can I use Kirkland Free & Clear for newborn clothes?
Yes. It is hypoallergenic, dye-free and perfume-free. A lot of parents use it for the whole family, newborn included. If your baby has a skin condition, ask your pediatrician first — that is true for any detergent.
Is Dreft fragrance-free?
No. Dreft Stage 1 has a light scent. If you need truly fragrance-free, pick a Free & Clear detergent.
Does Kirkland clean baby stains as well as Dreft?
In independent testing, Kirkland Ultra Clean liquid scored well and Consumer Reports ranked it among the top value detergents. For heavy spit-up and food stains, pre-treat the stain first, whichever detergent you use.
Do I need a Costco membership for Kirkland?
Yes. Kirkland is Costco-only. Gold Star membership is $65 a year. If you do not shop at Costco already, the membership alone wipes out the detergent saving — so only pick Kirkland if you already shop there.
Where can I buy Dreft?
Amazon, Walmart and Target all carry it. Our Amazon link below uses our Associates tag.
Affiliate Disclosure: Frugal Deals Hub may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Prices were checked on 2026-11-18 and can change. Always check the price at checkout.