Frugal Deals Hub is reader-supported. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links.
Home › Comparisons › Dixie vs Amazon Basics paper plates
By Darren · Published Nov 12, 2026 · Prices last verified Nov 12, 2026
How do Dixie vs Amazon Basics paper plates compare on cost per plate?
This post helps a shopper decide how Dixie vs Amazon Basics paper plates compare on cost per plate, Ultra vs Ultra and Everyday vs Everyday.
We used store-page prices only, divided each pack price by the plate count, and kept the two grades apart. This is simple division, not a hands-on test of the plates. All four priced packs are about 10 inches. Prices were checked Nov 12, 2026, at about 4:55 AM ET. No membership is required for any of these rows.
Table of Contents
BUY Amazon Basics Ultra Paper Plates, 100 count as the Ultra unit-price dupe. It was about $0.1149 per plate ($11.49), about 12% less per plate than Dixie Ultra Large Paper Plates, 172 count at about $0.1306 per plate ($22.47). That 12% is ($0.1306 − $0.1149) ÷ $0.1306. It is a price comparison only, not a claim that the plates perform the same. Dixie Ultra, sold by Amazon.com, is a fair pick for brand loyalists, but it is not the unit-price winner.
SKIP Dixie Everyday Paper Plates, 220 count at this listing on unit price. It was about $0.2318 per plate ($50.99), sold by third-party HOME&MOREUSA (medium confidence). Pick Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates, 150 count instead, at about $0.0933 per plate ($13.99). That Everyday pack is the cheapest verified unit in this check, but it is Everyday grade, not an Ultra dupe.




Dixie vs Amazon Basics paper plates: which pack costs less per plate?
Price status:
- Amazon Basics Ultra Paper Plates, 100 count (B0DN895DMC), $11.49: Price checked Nov 12, 2026, 4:55 AM ET at Amazon. Sold by Amazon.com. The listing title says 10 Inch; the pack label reads 10.06 in. We describe the size as about 10 in. No membership.
- Dixie Ultra Large Paper Plates, 172 count (4 packs of 43, B099BWGZBP), $22.47: Price checked Nov 12, 2026, 4:55 AM ET at Amazon. Sold by Amazon.com. The listing title says 10 Inch and one listing bullet says 10 1/2 in, but the pack and size option read 10 1/16 in, so we follow the pack. We describe the size as about 10 in. No membership.
- Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates, 150 count (B0C2CZJ1TK), $13.99: Price checked Nov 12, 2026, 4:55 AM ET at Amazon. Sold by Amazon.com. The listing title says 10 Inch; the pack label reads 10.06 in. We describe the size as about 10 in. No membership.
- Dixie Everyday Paper Plates, 220 count (5 sleeves of 44, B008R6LO5O), $50.99: Price checked Nov 12, 2026, 4:55 AM ET at Amazon. Sold by third-party HOME&MOREUSA (medium confidence). The listing title says 10 Inch; the pack reads 10 1/16 in. The pack is titled Everyday even if the page description mentions Dixie Ultra. No membership.
- Ultra rows are compared only with Ultra rows, and Everyday only with Everyday. Subscribe & Save and Amazon Resale prices are not used. Great Value and Chinet prices were UNVERIFIED and are not used. Costco.com had no Kirkland paper plate listed on Nov 12, 2026, for Seattle 98101; warehouse stock may differ. There is no Kirkland price and no membership-fee math in this post.
Ultra paper plates, cost per plate
| # | Retailer | Price | Qty | Membership / buy | Cost per unit | vs. best |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Amazon (Amazon Basics Ultra, 100 count) | $11.49 | 100 plate | — | $0.115/plate | Best |
| 2 | Amazon (Dixie Ultra, 172 count) | $22.47 | 172 plate | — | $0.131/plate | +13.7% |
Membership fees are spread across your purchases per year. Prices change often — confirm at the retailer.
Everyday paper plates, cost per plate
| # | Retailer | Price | Qty | Membership / buy | Cost per unit | vs. best |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Amazon (Amazon Basics Everyday, 150 count) | $13.99 | 150 plate | — | $0.093/plate | Best |
| 2 | Amazon (Dixie Everyday, 220 count, third-party) | $50.99 | 220 plate | — | $0.232/plate | +148.5% |
Membership fees are spread across your purchases per year. Prices change often — confirm at the retailer.
| Product | Grade | Sold by | Price | Count | Size | Per plate | Checked (ET) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon Basics Ultra Paper Plates | Ultra | Amazon.com | $11.49 | 100 | About 10 in (label 10.06 in) | $0.1149 | Nov 12, 4:55 AM |
| Dixie Ultra Large Paper Plates | Ultra | Amazon.com | $22.47 | 172 (4 × 43) | About 10 in (pack 10 1/16 in) | $0.1306 | Nov 12, 4:55 AM |
| Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates | Everyday | Amazon.com | $13.99 | 150 | About 10 in (label 10.06 in) | $0.0933 | Nov 12, 4:55 AM |
| Dixie Everyday Paper Plates | Everyday | HOME&MOREUSA (third-party) | $50.99 | 220 (5 sleeves of 44) | About 10 in (pack 10 1/16 in) | $0.2318 | Nov 12, 4:55 AM |
Prices last verified Nov 12, 2026, 4:55 AM ET. Amazon prices are as shown on the store page and may vary by ZIP and seller. The Amazon plate pages in this check did not show a delivery ZIP. We don’t have 90 days of our own verified prices, so we make no claims about recent lows or price history.
Why this verdict?
On Ultra packs, Amazon Basics Ultra is $11.49 ÷ 100 = $0.1149 per plate. Dixie Ultra is $22.47 ÷ 172 = $0.1306 per plate. The gap is ($0.1306 − $0.1149) ÷ $0.1306, or about 12% less per plate for Amazon Basics Ultra. That is a unit-price finding only. If you want the cheaper Ultra pack on these store pages, it is Amazon Basics Ultra. If you prefer the Dixie name, Dixie Ultra at $0.1306 is still a fair pick, just not the unit-price winner.
All four priced packs are about 10 inches, so the per-plate numbers are for similar-sized plates. The listing titles all say 10 Inch. The Dixie packs (Ultra and Everyday) read 10 1/16 in, and the Amazon Basics labels (Ultra and Everyday) read 10.06 in. We still describe them as about 10 in and report those box facts rather than inventing a single diameter. The Dixie Everyday 220-count pack is 5 sleeves of 44.
The Dixie Everyday pack is the outlier. At $50.99 for 220 plates, it is $50.99 ÷ 220 = $0.2318 per plate, and it is sold by third-party HOME&MOREUSA, not by Amazon.com, so our confidence in that price is medium. The pack is titled Everyday; the page description mentions Dixie Ultra, which can confuse things, so we treat it as Everyday because that is what the title says. Against Amazon Basics Everyday at $13.99 ÷ 150 = $0.0933 per plate, this Dixie Everyday listing is not close on price. Amazon Basics Everyday is the cheapest verified unit in this check, but it is an Everyday pack, not an Ultra dupe. This is a price comparison only; we did not test the plates.
Who should skip Dixie at these prices?
- Everyday shoppers looking at this Dixie Everyday listing. At $0.2318 per plate from a third-party seller, it costs much more per plate than Amazon Basics Everyday at $0.0933. Skip this listing on unit price.
- Shoppers who only want the lowest Ultra unit price. Amazon Basics Ultra is about 12% less per plate than Dixie Ultra. Dixie Ultra can still make sense if you already prefer that brand and the gap does not bother you.
- Anyone hoping to add a Kirkland row. Costco.com had no Kirkland paper plate listed on Nov 12, 2026, for Seattle 98101. Warehouse stock may differ. We did not invent a price.
What are the unit-price picks?
The Ultra unit-price pick is Amazon Basics Ultra, 100 count, at $11.49, or $0.1149 per plate. The Everyday pick is Amazon Basics Everyday, 150 count, at $13.99, or $0.0933 per plate. We are not adding other brands, because we did not verify those prices.
For the same cost-per-unit method on other paper goods, see Kirkland vs Charmin toilet paper, also priced per sheet. That post is about toilet paper, not plates. For other kitchen staples, see Kirkland vs Reynolds aluminum foil, Kirkland plastic wrap vs Reynolds, and Kirkland vs Reynolds parchment paper.
How we calculated cost per plate
Cost per plate = Total price ÷ Number of plates
| Brand/pack | Pack price | Plates in pack | Cost per plate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon Basics Ultra | $11.49 | 100 | $0.11 |
| Dixie Ultra | $22.47 | 172 | $0.13 |
| Amazon Basics Everyday | $13.99 | 150 | $0.09 |
| Dixie Everyday | $50.99 | 220 | $0.23 |
Amazon Basics Ultra costs about 12% less per plate than Dixie Ultra.
We compared published prices and listings and did not test the plates. We used the one-time store-page price for each pack, with no membership fee added, and we didn’t use Subscribe & Save or Amazon Resale prices.
A Dixie Everyday/Large 204-count listing had no featured offer, and an Amazon Basics Everyday 150-count pack of 2 was unavailable, so neither is in the table. We also didn’t use comparison-card figures as prices.
Costco.com had no Kirkland paper plate listed on Nov 12, 2026, for Seattle 98101. Warehouse stock may differ, so there’s no Kirkland unit price and no membership-fee math.
What do shoppers ask about Dixie and Amazon Basics paper plates?
Is Amazon Basics Ultra cheaper per plate than Dixie Ultra?
On the store pages we checked, yes. Amazon Basics Ultra is $0.1149 per plate and Dixie Ultra is $0.1306 per plate, or about 12% less per plate. That is a price comparison only, not a claim about how the plates perform.
Can I compare Everyday plates to Ultra plates?
Not as a 1:1 match. Everyday and Ultra are different listing grades, so this post compares Ultra only with Ultra and Everyday only with Everyday. Amazon Basics Everyday at $0.0933 per plate is the cheapest verified unit here, but it is not an Ultra dupe.
Is the Dixie Everyday price worth it?
Not at this listing’s price. The Dixie Everyday pack comes to $0.2318 per plate and is sold by third-party HOME&MOREUSA, so it is a medium-confidence price. Amazon Basics Everyday is $0.0933 per plate. We would skip this Dixie listing on unit price.
Did you find a Kirkland paper plate price at Costco?
No. Costco.com had no Kirkland paper plate listed on Nov 12, 2026, for Seattle 98101. Warehouse stock may differ, so we did not guess at a price.
Where do these prices come from?
- Amazon: Amazon Basics Ultra Paper Plates, 10 inch, 100 count (B0DN895DMC)
- Amazon: Dixie Ultra Large Paper Plates, 172 count (B099BWGZBP)
- Amazon: Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates, 10 inch, 150 count (B0C2CZJ1TK)
- Amazon: Dixie Everyday Paper Plates, 220 count (B008R6LO5O) — third-party seller HOME&MOREUSA