Home › Comparisons › Costco vs Sam’s Club Diapers
By Darren · Published November 4, 2026 · Prices last verified Nov 9, 2026, 8:15 AM ET
Verdict: BUY
Cheapest diapers per diaper: Kirkland Signature diapers cost less per diaper in every size we could verify, even at their regular price. In size 4, Kirkland is about $0.20 per diaper at Costco warehouses ($39.99 for 198, Costco.com and Warehouse Runner), versus $0.23 for Member’s Mark (via Instacart Same-Day, out of stock) and about $0.32 for Huggies. Size 5 is $0.238 ($39.99 for 168). With an estimated fee share, Kirkland size 4 is about $0.23. A $10 manufacturer instant savings that ran Oct 26–Nov 8 has ended. As of Nov 9, 8:15 AM ET, Costco.com online and in-warehouse are both $39.99 with no sale tag (size 4 #1987114, 198 ct; size 5 #1987115, 168 ct).
Kirkland Ultra Soft Diapers — size 3
Costco Same-Day
$34.04 · 222 diapers
$0.153 per diaper
With fee share: $0.178 per diaper
Checked Nov 4, 2026, 4:57 AM ET
Sale price against a $44.04 original.
Kirkland Ultra Soft Diapers — size 4
Costco Same-Day
$34.04 · 198 diapers
$0.172 per diaper
With fee share: $0.199 per diaper
Checked Nov 4, 2026, 4:57 AM ET
Sale price against a $44.04 original.
Member’s Mark Premium Baby Diapers — size 3
Sam’s Club via Instacart Same-Day
$45.98 · 234 diapers
$0.196 per diaper
With fee share: $0.218 per diaper
Checked Nov 4, 2026, 4:57 AM ET
Out of stock on Same-Day. Sam’sclub.com lists Member’s Mark Premium from $16.98 but we couldn’t load size-level club prices.
Kirkland Ultra Soft Diapers — size 4
Costco warehouse
$39.99 · 198 diapers
$0.202 per diaper
With fee share: $0.229 per diaper
If joining only for this (one box, size 4): $0.530 per diaper
Checked Nov 9, 2026, 8:15 AM ET
Regular price confirmed on Costco.com Nov 9, 8:15 AM ET (online and in-warehouse; no sale tag). The $10 manufacturer instant savings (Oct 26–Nov 8, 2026) has ended.
Kirkland Ultra Soft Diapers — size 5
Costco Same-Day
$34.04 · 168 diapers
$0.203 per diaper
With fee share: $0.235 per diaper
Checked Nov 4, 2026, 4:57 AM ET
Sale price against a $44.04 original.
Member’s Mark Premium Baby Diapers — size 4
Sam’s Club via Instacart Same-Day
$48.78 · 210 diapers
$0.232 per diaper
With fee share: $0.256 per diaper
If joining only for this (one box, size 4): $0.518 per diaper
Checked Nov 4, 2026, 4:57 AM ET
Out of stock on Same-Day.
Kirkland Ultra Soft Diapers — size 5
Costco warehouse
$39.99 · 168 diapers
$0.238 per diaper
With fee share: $0.270 per diaper
Checked Nov 9, 2026, 8:15 AM ET
Regular price confirmed on Costco.com Nov 9, 8:15 AM ET (online and in-warehouse; no sale tag). The $10 manufacturer instant savings (Oct 26–Nov 8, 2026) has ended.
Member’s Mark Premium Baby Diapers — size 5
Sam’s Club via Instacart Same-Day
$45.98 · 168 diapers
$0.274 per diaper
With fee share: $0.303 per diaper
Checked Nov 4, 2026, 4:57 AM ET
Huggies Plus Little Movers Diapers — size 4
Costco Same-Day
$56.74 · 180 diapers
$0.315 per diaper
With fee share: $0.345 per diaper
Checked Nov 4, 2026, 4:57 AM ET
Huggies Little Movers Plus Diapers — size 4
Sam’s Club via Instacart Same-Day
$57.48 · 180 diapers
$0.319 per diaper
With fee share: $0.347 per diaper
Checked Nov 4, 2026, 4:57 AM ET
With-fee figures are estimates: Costco $65/yr ÷ 12 trips ≈ $5.42; Sam’s Club $60/yr ÷ 12 trips = $5.00, charged to this one item. See Costco’s membership page and Sam’s Club’s join page. Kirkland warehouse/online price $39.99 confirmed on Costco.com Nov 9, 8:15 AM ET (online and in-warehouse; no sale tag) and on Warehouse Runner (latest average $39.99; ignore the tracker’s historical low headline and stale average field). Costco Same-Day Kirkland prices ($34.04) are sale prices against a $44.04 original. Huggies: we could verify size 4 only. Kirkland size 3 warehouse price not shown (the tracked item was out or low at most warehouses, with prices from $24.97 to $39.99). Same-Day prices on both services can be higher than in-club prices.



Which are the cheapest diapers per diaper, Costco or Sam’s Club?
BUY — Kirkland size 4: $0.202 per diaper at the $39.99 warehouse price ($0.229 with an estimated $5.42 fee share); size 5 is $0.238. Member’s Mark size 4 is $0.232 ($0.256 with fee) via Instacart Same-Day, and out of stock there; Huggies is $0.315–$0.319.
What do Kirkland, Member’s Mark and Huggies cost per diaper by size (Nov 9, 2026)?
Real Value Matrix
| # | Retailer | Price | Qty | Membership / buy | Cost per unit | vs. best |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Costco Same-Day (Kirkland size 4, 198 ct) | $34.04 | 198 ct | — | $0.172/ct | Best |
| 2 | Costco warehouse (Kirkland size 4, 198 ct, regular price) | $39.99 | 198 ct | — | $0.202/ct | +17.5% |
| 3 | Sam’s Club via Instacart Same-Day (Member’s Mark size 4, 210 ct, out of stock) | $48.78 | 210 ct | — | $0.232/ct | +35.1% |
| 4 | Costco Same-Day (Huggies Plus size 4, 180 ct) | $56.74 | 180 ct | — | $0.315/ct | +83.4% |
| 5 | Sam’s Club via Instacart Same-Day (Huggies Little Movers Plus size 4, 180 ct) | $57.48 | 180 ct | — | $0.319/ct | +85.7% |
Membership fees are spread across your purchases per year. Prices change often — confirm at the retailer.
Joining just for diapers (size 4, one box): Kirkland ($39.99 + $65) ÷ 198 = $0.530 per diaper; Member’s Mark ($48.78 + $60) ÷ 210 = $0.518 per diaper. Over a year of buying, the fee spreads across many boxes and matters much less.
Prices last verified Nov 9, 2026, 8:15 AM ET (Costco.com + Warehouse Runner Kirkland size 4/5). Same-Day $34.04 and Member’s Mark / Huggies rows still use Nov 4 checks. We don’t have 90 days of our own verified prices, so we make no claims about lows or history.
Why does Kirkland come out ahead?
At the warehouse price, Kirkland size 4 is $0.202 per diaper and Member’s Mark (via Instacart Same-Day) is $0.232, a gap of about $0.03, or about $6 per 200 diapers. In size 5 the gap is wider: $0.238 versus $0.274. Kirkland is about a third less per diaper than Huggies at either club, and Member’s Mark about a quarter less.
The fee doesn’t change the order. With an estimated one-trip share of the fee, Kirkland size 4 is $0.229 at the warehouse price and Member’s Mark is $0.256. We compared label specs and prices only; we didn’t test fit or leaks. Costco’s Same-Day listing for Kirkland size 4 lists a “Hypoallergenic Liner,” “Up to 12 Hours of Absorbent Protection” and a “Pocketed Waistband for Blowouts.” We don’t make health claims beyond the label; ask your pediatrician about skin concerns.
Is a 198-count box of Kirkland size 4 worth it for you?
Who should skip the big Kirkland box?
- Babies close to sizing up: a 198-count size 4 box lasts weeks, and leftovers may not fit. Costco limit: Limit of 5 transactions, maximum 5 units per membership every 7 days (per Costco.com, Nov 9).
- Families already loyal to Huggies for fit or skin reasons; a leak that ruins clothes erases the savings.
- Non-members buying one box: joining just for diapers puts the first size 4 box near $0.53 per diaper.
What are the alternatives if your size is out of stock?
Member’s Mark size 3 and 4 were out of stock on Sam’s Club via Instacart Same-Day on Nov 4; check Sam’s Club diapers for in-club stock. Without a membership, check Huggies on Amazon, Walmart or Target; we didn’t verify those prices. More deals: Black Friday deals hub.
How did we calculate it?
Price ÷ count, e.g. $39.99 ÷ 198 = $0.2020; $39.99 ÷ 168 = $0.2380; $48.78 ÷ 210 = $0.2323; $56.74 ÷ 180 = $0.3152. With fee: ($39.99 + $5.42) ÷ 198 = $0.2293; ($48.78 + $5.00) ÷ 210 = $0.2561. The 12-trips figure is an assumption. See how we calculate Real Value for the full method.
Costco vs Sam’s Club diapers: shopper questions
Are Kirkland diapers cheaper than Huggies?
Yes. For the cheapest price per diaper in size 4, Kirkland was $0.202 per diaper at the $39.99 warehouse/online price versus about $0.315 for Huggies Plus on Costco Same-Day (Huggies price last checked Nov 4).
How much are Member’s Mark diapers per diaper?
Via Instacart Same-Day for Sam’s Club: $0.196 (size 3), $0.232 (size 4) and $0.274 (size 5). Sizes 3 and 4 showed out of stock there.
Is a Costco membership worth it just for diapers?
Not for a single box. At about 200 diapers a month, Kirkland size 4 at $39.99 saves roughly $6 a month versus Member’s Mark via Instacart Same-Day (estimate), so the fee can pay off over a year.
Do Costco diaper sales happen often?
A $10 manufacturer instant savings on Kirkland size 4 and 5 ran Oct 26–Nov 8, 2026, and has ended. As of Nov 9, 8:15 AM ET, Costco.com online and in-warehouse both show $39.99 with no sale tag. We don’t have enough history to say how often sales like that return.